EU red carpet for Azerbaijan sends wrong message

 euobserver.com Opinion. By Giorgi Gogia. Brussels - 06/02 (Photo:ec.europa.eu)

The European Union’s “quiet diplomacy” just got much quieter. With one strongman in particular, it is almost inaudible. Remarkably, Brussels dragged its feet to inform the public of an upcoming visit by Azerbaijan president Ilham Aliyev, who is coming to town on Monday (6 February) to personally inaugurate negotiations on a new EU-Azerbaijan partnership agreement.

The deal is set to strengthen the political and economic ties between the union and its oil-rich neighbour to the south east.

A state visit and a new partnership negotiation usually come with a lot of fanfare. Why all the reluctance to share the date of his visit? The lack of transparency is hardly surprising from Baku’s side.

The authorities in Azerbaijan are extremely hostile to public scrutiny and accountability, and this very hostility is at core of the crackdown on critics, opposition activists, journalists and other dissenting voices for many years. But the secrecy around the visit suggests that Baku’s deeply problematic approaches to transparency are rubbing off on the EU.

Is the EU really so quick to set aside its own commitments to transparency and accountability? Apparently so. During more than a dozen official meetings my colleague and I had on 26 and 27 January in Brussels, officials were extremely tightlipped about Aliyev’s visit.

Once we understood it was in the works, and pressed for some, any, information, officials and diplomats flatly refused to share the date of the visit. One member-state diplomat, clearly uncomfortable with the “gag order,” eventually acknowledged that there was an agreement that the date would not be communicated beyond the hallowed walls of European External Action Service and the member state diplomats.

It was not until late last week when the date of the visit became official after the calendar of the European Commission president was updated online.

Does the EU fear publicity of Aliyev’s trip to Brussels and inevitable criticism of Azerbaijan’s human rights record and the EU’s failure in pressing for reforms? It may fear it, but that criticism would be well-earned.

Well-earned criticism

Beyond arresting, prosecuting, harassing and exiling critics, the Aliyev government also implements draconian laws and regulations restricting independent groups and their ability to secure funding.

Even major EU donors, like the European Endowment for Democracy, and other donors across Europe are shut out of Azerbaijan. This means independent groups in Azerbaijan providing essential services and protecting the rights of citizens against government abuses can’t get the funds they need to operate. They will not survive much longer. Meanwhile, the EU seems to care little, forging ahead towards the economic benefits it hopes to reap. The vicious crackdown had drawn vocal condemnation from many of Azerbaijan’s international partners, including two strongly-worded resolutions from the European Parliament in 2014 and 2015.

Baku, again, in an overheated response to criticism, almost entirely disengaged from political dialogue with the EU in 2015. Earlier in 2016, the Azerbaijani authorities freed 17 human rights defenders, journalists, and political activists imprisoned on politically motivated charges. Many in the EU rushed to congratulate Aliyev on the releases and sought to frame the move as an indication of a shift in Azerbaijan’s punitive attitude towards its critics.

The EU and Azerbaijan gradually restored most of their bilateral ties, and in November 2016 the European Council approved a mandate for the Commission to negotiate the new framework agreement with Azerbaijan. But the EU and others were far too quick to heap praise: none of these individuals should have been detained in the first place, and worse the government simply arrested new critics it did not like to take their place behind bars.

Empty gesture

Since the releases, there has been no fundamental human rights turnaround from Baku. It has relentlessly pursued the political opposition, youth activists, bloggers and others. It even goes after the relatives of those who have fled abroad, including to the EU, to escape persecution. Many activists convicted in politically motivated trials between 2013 and 2015 remain in prison. Those released have not had their convictions quashed, which can limit their activism. Many face travel bans. They will see how Aliyev gets the EU’s red carpet treatment; meanwhile, they cannot even make it to Brussels.

Under such circumstances, deepening engagement with Aliyev’s government, without first securing concrete and sustainable human rights improvements sends a wrong message about the EU’s priorities, and is bad for the EU.

The EU stands to benefit far more from a partnership with a country that respects rule of law and human rights, than one that cannot be trusted to do so. As EU officials quietly prepare to roll out the red carpet and treat the Azerbaijani strongman with fanfare, it should make sure that this deepening relationship is the one adhering to its own principles of “democracy, the rule of law, the universality and indivisibility of human rights and fundamental freedoms,” as it committed to in all of its negotiations with third party countries.

Transparency is a key part of that. While the new agreement is up for the negotiations, the EU’s principles of transparency and accountability should not be up for grabs.

Giorgi Gogia is South Caucasus Director at Human Rights Watch

Photo: Aliyev was also courted by the former European Commission Jose Manuel Barroso

Hay Online Pdf

DPCalendar Upcoming

21 Sep
HAYDOUN en Fête ! CONCERT de Harutyun CHKOLYAN pour l'Anniversaire de l'Indépendance de l'Arménie - 21/09
Date 21.09.2019 19:30

indpendance fte bis

25 Oct
CONCERT: TSIRANI ENSEMBLE (Armenia) - 25/10
Date 25.10.2019 20:00

Vendredi 25 octobre 2019 de 20:00 à 23:00
Organisé par Muziekpublique - muziekpublique.be
Théâtre Molière - Galerie de la Porte de Namur, 3 Square du Bastion, 1050 Bruxelles

Tsirani Ensemble :
Georgy Minasyan: duduk, shvi
Davit Avagyan: tar
Mariam Mirzoyan: oud
Gor Ghalmukhyan: percussion
Artak Asatryan: solo duduk, artistic direction


Info & tickets NL: https://bit.ly/2ZN0KMu
Info & billets FR: https://bit.ly/2OOU8wb
https://fr-fr.facebook.com/events/471868860272278/

En Arménie, les abricotiers poussent dans la vallée de l’Ararat et au pied des montagnes adjacentes. Le fruit à la peau feutrée est donc présent dans de nombreux aspects de la vie arménienne : Il y a plusieurs siècles, les rois arméniens portaient des robes couleur d’abricot, de grands compositeurs arméniens tels que Komitas et Ashough Djivani ont composé des chansons portant le titre « L’Abricotier » et ce n’est sans doute pas un hasard si le duduk, l’instrument national à anche double, est fabriqué à partir de bois d’abricot.

L’ensemble Tsirani, ou Ensemble de l’abricotier, a bien choisi son nom pour interpréter la musique et les chansons traditionnelles arméniennes dans toute leur diversité: ils reprennent des mélodies médiévales, la musique folklorique et celle des troubadours, des compositions de Komitas… Leur ensemble instrumental et vocal partage toute la palette de sons et d’émotions présentes dans la musique arménienne. A travers cette musique séculaire, nous goûtons la douceur des fruits, de la culture et de l’histoire arménienne.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=14&v=8fbchaE0EyI

20 Nov
CONCERT The NAGHASH Ensemble of Armenia - 20/11
Date 20.11.2019 20:00

The Naghash Ensemble en tournée en Europe avec « Songs of Exile »

« Trois brillantes chanteuses et quelques-uns des meilleurs musiciens d’Arménie au duduk, à l’oud, au dhôl et au piano. » ADK

Vendredi 20 novembre 2019 à 20h00

De Singel (Blauwe zaal), Desguinlei 25. B 2018 Antwerpen

Tickets +32 (0)3 248 28 28 / Cette adresse e-mail est protégée contre les robots spammeurs. Vous devez activer le JavaScript pour la visualiser.

14 Déc
CONCERT Nara NOÏAN et Vardan HOVANISSIAN - 14/12
Date 14.12.2019 20:00

Nara Noïan & Vardan Hovanissian présente - « Oriental Express »

Un dialogue entre l’Orient et l’Occident.
Un espoir pour un monde meilleur, un monde sans peur.
“Oriental Express” est un cri du cœur, un appel à la Paix, à l’écoute de l’être humain.
C’est l'histoire d'une femme nomade à travers l’exile, l’amour, la passion, la rupture, la maternité, le voyage, la sensualité, la colère aussi.

Au programme, des compositions de Nara Noïan issues de ses 7 albums : « Bradyaga », « Cristal », «Kino », « Oriental Express », «NR 5 » « Shadows & Lights », « Les regrets inutiles » et des musiques traditionnelles russes et arméniennes.
« Oriental Express » est le fruit d’une vie de Nara Noïan, artiste française, née « Anna-Naïra Pavlovna Mnoian » à Erevan, en république soviétique d’Arménie, et immigrée en France en 1990, juste avant la chute de l’Union Soviétique.
Elle rencontre en Belgique Vardan Hovanissian grace au groupe « Arax » fondé par Tigran Ter-Stepanian.
Une grande complicité et amitié s’installe entre Vardan, Tigan et Nara. Ils collaborent ensembles depuis 2007.
Musiques de paix, vagabondes, joyeuses, sensuelles et mélancoliques parfois.
L’univers personnel développé dans ses compositions donne envie de prendre la route, de se perdre dans les confins du rêve et de l’inconscient et d’être transporté, aux sons du duduk, shvi, clarinette, de piano et de la voix sur les sentiers de son exil.
Un spectacle très féminin et humaniste, tout en émotion, grâce, élégance, joie, engagement, douceur, avec de l’humour et de la séduction.